Ok. I want to start a new series, we’ll see how this goes. Art Review Friday.
Some of you know that I have a deep love of art (some of you don’t). And, currently, I’m lacking that piece of myself and would like to resurrect it in some small way. I’ll pick an artist and subsequent piece and talk about it some; I also want to see what you all think.
First, I would like to set some ground rules. Even if no one chooses to participate on this forum, remember these guidelines for the future.
1. A discussion about art should never be disrespectful. Sometimes, it can get as heated as a chat about religion or politics (as it often depicts said topics) and because of this it’s important to remember that I’m advocating discussing, not blaming, arguing, trying to prove overall superiority. We are here to talk about each of our experiences we gain from art.
2. Second, please don’t say “it reminds me of (fill in the blank),” or “it looks like (blank).” Because then all people will be able to see what was contrived out of your memory and will have difficulty describing their own, unique experience. It was always look like (blank) if you say it out loud.
3. Also, NEVER EVER tell me “I don’t like it.” I don’t care that you don’t like it. What “qualities” does it have that makes it so undesirable–keep in mind the artist might not want it to be aesthetically pleasing, but instead to evoke an emotion from its veiwer. If you must tell me you dislike it, tell me (very descriptive) why. And almost worse than “I don’t like it,” is “I like it.” So? Tell me about your experience. You can’t discuss “I like it.” Ugh….Art Critique 101.
4. And most importantly, please remember that once an artist has completed and displayed a work they become two separate entities. Do not talk about the work in referencing the artist (the work is not the artist). Instead talk about the piece, ie. “I wish it had more variance in brush strokes,” NOT “I wish the artist varied brush strokes more.” or “I would have liked the piece to have repeated this element again as it feels out-of-place.” NOT “I wish the artist wouldn’t have made this mark only once because it’s not making sense.” Get it? Great!
So, recap: Be respectful; Don’t tell us what it specifically resembles/reminds you of; Always tell me WHY; Critique the art, not the artist.
Let’s Begin!
Robert Adams, The Place We Live, Our Parents Our Children, Photograph
Denver CO circa 1981
(Robert Adams Currently Has an Exhibition at the Denver Art Museum called “The Places We Live.” You should check it out.)
I love this Photograph, and here is why. It shares the same characteristics the photos I would have stored up on my point and shoot. It’s every day, it’s routine, it’s relatable to so many people. Even though this was taken in the early eighties it’s a scene I could have seen just yesterday (minus the dated fashion).
The series this photo is taken from is called “Our Parents, Our Children.” It shows a mother and her two children, the youngest being assisted by their Grandmother. Now that I have kids, it seems necessary for more than one set of arms, especially when traveling anywhere! I think it also shows an innate obligation/responsibility/desire to help our children, even if it means helping our children with their children. It’s tender in a way despite the mundane activity of packing up kids into the car. I appreciate that it seems as though the little girl is reluctant to pack up and leave in that small car, and that it appears her mother is trying to negotiate with her. Although, if I wasn’t intentional about looking at this piece, or if I hadn’t browsed the series as a whole before I posted this, I might pass on by it for something that appears to be more striking right off the bat. But, I’m glad I did take some time on this photo.